The charge of 'controlled opposition' is regularly hurled at a variety of sites and individuals on the Alt-Right, usually because of a disagreement over something inconsequential. Alex Jones is the exemplar. Funded by Jews, he seeks to deflect attention away from Jewish involvement in 9/11 and his wife is, or was, Jewish. Anyway, it seems he's controlled opposition. Even the Daily Stormer's Andrew Anglin has been thus designated by several commentators on this site.
It seems to me that those charges are laid if the target doesn't fully and unconditionally meet all the requirements demanded of a perfect WN. But remember perfect is the enemy of good enough. There will always be disagreements about facts, priorities, interpretations, measures to take etc. That's the nature of any movement. The criterion should be 'is he (or the site) helping or damaging the WN cause?'.
When assessed this way almost all charges of controlled opposition dissolve. Even in the case of Alex Jones. Despite carefully avoiding the Third Rail he has worked wonders in waking White people up. He has induced Whites to question and doubt the narrative they've been fed by schools, Government, MSM and Hollywood. Look, time and again he talks about “the elite”, “the global elites”, “globalists”, “international bankers”, “global conspiracy”, “the NWO” and the like. He says that every path leads to the House of Rothschild. Now I ask you, how much more explicit do you expect him to be? It doesn’t take a great leap of the imagination to establish the connection here.
Or take someone like Stefan Molyneux. His mother was Jewish and he too tries to downplay the Jewish role in the war on Whites. But he has done, and continues to do, tremendous valuable work in waking Whites up to the terrible dangers posed by feminism, mass immigration, so-called liberalism and the White Privilege meme among others. I repeat, he (and other so-called controlled opposition sites like his) contributes greatly to waking White people up. And that is the main challenge facing WNs. Our biggest problem is that the overwhelming majority of Whites have no understanding - whatsoever - of the war being waged against them. They believe in what they see on TV and the movies, in what they learn in school and university and as such are like lemmings heading unknowingly towards the cliff.
Why would any 'controller' support such messages of awakening? Remember, and I'm living testimony to this fact, once you start pulling at the Narrative string the whole thing comes apart like a cheap suit. Any 'controller' worth his salt knows that and would avoid it like the plague. That's why Kevin Myers and James Damore were summarily fired.
So please, be judicious in deploying the charge of controlled opposition simply because the target's position doesn't conform exactly with yours. We are still a small minority and desperately need any help we can get in rousing Whites from their potentially fatal slumber.
In similar vein it does not help our cause by categorising in scatter-gun fashion everyone who is against us as Jewish. To paraphrase one comment on the previous post on this blog: Hitler could have been partly Jewish because his grandfather was illegitimate and his biological father could therefore have been Jewish. Ipso facto Hitler was 'controlled opposition'. Can you see how ridiculous this stuff can get?
So please, welcome any help we can get. If you disagree with people like AJ or SM take the issue up with them in a constructive way in their blogs. And there are more than enough people of real Jewish heritage trying to take us down without assigning non-Jews to that category.
Forward!